Megan Hilty and Nick Jonas
INF; Pacific Coast News
03/01/2012 at 06:00 AM EST
Time for a midnight nosh!
's Megan Hilty
grabbed a late-night bite together after taping Andy Cohen
's Bravo talk show, Watch What Happens Live.
The costars (Jonas guest-starred on a recent episode of the NBC show) snacked at Cafeteria in New York's Chelsea neighborhood. "They were laughing and talking while sharing the mac attack appetizer," a source tells PEOPLE.
For the main dish, Nick ordered meatloaf with garlic mashed potatoes, sautéed green beans and oven-roasted tomato relish, while Megan had the pear salad. And for dessert, the two shared apple pie ravioli. – Linda Marx