Caught in the Act

Scarlett Johansson's Late-Night Hipster Hangout with Her Beau

04/05/2012 at 06:00 AM EDT

Scarlett Johansson had a late date night with boyfriend Nate Naylor at New York hipster hangout Cabin Down Below. The couple was super chill and low-key as they sat next to indie rock band The Naked and the Famous at the bar.

The two were deep in conversation, according to an onlooker, and showed no obvious PDA. Still, they were talking quite close and appeared to be in deep conversation. Johansson, in a dark blue shirt over a black tank top, and Naylor occasionally chatted with the band, though they were seated separately at their own table. The bar was playing old rock and soul tunes, but they didn't dance at all.

Also there: Alexa Chung, who was sitting with friends at a table in the other room.

NEXT: Lea Michele Enjoys Poolside R&R in Palm Springs