Carrie Underwood's New Album, Blown Away, Reviewed

Carrie Underwood Blown Away - 2.5 Star People Review
Carrie Underwood

05/01/2012 AT 04:25 PM EDT

bgwhite bgwhite   

Carrie Underwood's fourth album, Blown Away, comes on like a tornado with its first three songs.

There's the guitar-charged single "Good Girl," which, with all of its rock bluster, is maybe the least country thing she's ever done. Then there's the windswept title track, an over-the-top tale about a twister wiping out the house where an alcoholic father abused his daughter.

Underwood keeps in melodramatic mode with "Two Black Cadillacs," a macabre revenge song. You may be exhausted after getting through all of that, but brace yourself for more overproduced, under-nuanced action – this is big-hair country. Fortunately, though, relief comes in the wistful, piano-laced "Forever Changed."

Three other ballads – the nostalgic "Thank God for Hometowns," the bittersweet "Good in Goodbye" and the sobering "Wine After Whiskey" – are even better. Best of the uptempo numbers is "Cupid's Got a Shotgun," featuring no less a guitar slinger than Brad Paisley – and adding some double-barreled fun to all the high drama.

For more music, TV and movie reviews, pick up the latest issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands Friday
blog comments powered by Disqus

From Our Partners