Gerard Butler and Gabriel Aubry Hit Hollywood Hotelier's Birthday Bash
05/04/2012 AT 05:55 AM EDT
Stepping out solo, the ladies' man arrived shortly after Gabriel Aubry showed up. Both men were just in time for the dinner portion of the bash, which started around 8 p.m. and ended at 2 a.m.
The two men didn't sit together or interact much, but the 50-person party also included Entourage cast mates Jerry Ferrara and Emmanuelle Chriqui, along with Harry Morton and Peter Gallagher.
"Gabriel was looking pretty sharp in a suit," a partygoer tells PEOPLE. "The female guests were chit-chatting all night, trying to find out his [relationship] 'status.' "
– Dahvi Shira