Melissa Rycroft & Tye Strickland Make It a Comedy Date Night
05/07/2012 AT 05:55 AM EDT
According to an onlooker, the couple was "very cuddly" and held hands at the show when Tye didn't have his arm around Melissa. "They are just so in love and just so cute," says the onlooker.
The two had a sip of wine before the show began, but ultimately raced to their seats, where they laughed at the performances before leaving the grab sushi and head home to daughter Ava.