Kelly Rowland, Beyoncé and Gwyneth Paltrow
Courtesy Derwin Gray
When Jay-Z took the stage with Kanye West
in Paris, he had the support of his No. 1 fan: wife Beyoncé
The new mom
, 30, joined by pals Gwyneth Paltrow
and Kelly Rowland, looked on from the VIP section
of the Palais Omnisports de Paris-Bercy as the two rappers rocked through a three-hour set list Friday. Justin Bieber
also attended the show, which included a 50-plus-minute remix of hit "N----- in Paris."
Not singing along: West's girlfriend
, Kim Kardashian
, who didn't make it out to the first of three sold-out Watch the Throne tour stops in the City of Lights. Also missing: Jay-Z's other No. 1 fan, baby Blue Ivy Carter
, nearly 5 months, who presumably stayed back at the hotel.
PEOPLE's reigning World's Most Beautiful Woman
, donning a white shift dress, left the arena via the dock chute – the same covert way she came – to head to the hotel, reportedly on the Champs-Elysees.