06/06/2012 AT 11:45 AM EDT
It's been done many times before: The winning contestant on The Bachelor
or The Bachelorette
finds true love. And then the relationship falls apart and they return to the show as the ones handing out the roses.
But will Roberto Martinez, whose breakup from Ali Fedotowsky
came after an 18-month engagement
, follow suit?
"It's far too soon to say who the next Bachelor will be, but Roberto is definitely someone producers are considering," a source close to the show tells PEOPLE.
While there's no word on whether Martinez, 29, is interested in again pursuing love on reality TV, the source says he fits the bill.
"Obviously there's a lot about Roberto that is appealing," the source says. "Still, they also want to see who from Emily Maynard's current season might pop with viewers and are weighing if there are any contenders there. It's just too soon to tell."
But it's not too soon to tell us what you think! Vote in our poll below: