Suri Cruise Leaves Pet Store Without Puppy

Katie Holmes, Suri Cruise at Pet Store
Katie Holmes and Suri Cruise
James Devaney/Wireimage

07/16/2012 AT 03:15 PM EDT

First goats and alpacas, now puppies. Suri Cruise is definitely making a lot of new friends in Manhattan!

The 6-year-old was spotted playing with dogs in a fenced-in cage Saturday at West Village pet store Citipups, where she spied a Yorkshire terrier/Maltese mix she wanted to bring home.

Sadly, mother and daughter left the shop empty-handed – but could their three-bedroom downtown apartment soon be filled with the happy clatter of puppy feet? Stay tuned!

Can't get enough pet news? See more on PEOPLE Pets

Good Morning! Miley Cyrus & Ziggy Say Hello

Kim Kardashian Goes Bareback on a Horse

MORE ON: Katie Holmes

From Our Partners