Caught in the Act

Tim Tebow Tackles the West Hollywood Dining Scene

07/17/2012 at 06:00 AM EDT

Tim Tebow is taking the most of his off-season! The football star headed out in West Hollywood on Saturday, where he went to dinner with a group of people at hotspot Craig's.

Tebow and seven friends – including a mystery woman – took over a back corner table.

Clad in jeans and a light blue T-shirt, Tebow sat close to a tall young, brunette woman, an onlooker tells PEOPLE. "She wasn't famous," the onlooker says. "She was skinny with long, dark hair and appeared to be in her early 20s."

But even with a young lady by his side, the source says, "He focused his attention on the men in the group as they all talked about football and were laughing and joking, seeming to enjoy their conversation."
– Marisa Laudadio

Spot a celebrity? Tweet us your sighting @peoplemag with #CITA and it could appear on PEOPLE.com!

— People magazine (@peoplemag) August 7, 2012

NEXT: Tobey Maguire Skips the Meat During Steakhouse Dinner with Leo DiCaprio