08/01/2012 at 06:00 AM EDT
It was all about the boys for Channing Tatum
on Saturday evening.
The Magic Mike
star had a guys night out in N.Y.C. at Toy, where his group dined at around 10 p.m.
Tatum, who sipped on a glass of red wine with his meal, ordered the special "off the menu" filet mignon with sautéed veggies, according to an onlooker.
"[The night] was super casual," the source tells PEOPLE. "Channing seemed super humble and cool." – Kristin Boehm