Inside the SYTYCD Judges' Deliberations on Who to Send Home

08/23/2012 at 03:15 PM EDT

So You Think You Can Dance: Inside the Judges' Deliberations
So You Think You Can Dance contestants Audrey Case and George Lawerence II
FOX (2)
All-stars raised the So You Think You Can Dance finalists to a new level Wednesday, but two contestants still went home after a night of stellar performances.

"The all-stars could have taken all of the thunder and stolen all the light, but that wasn't the case," judge Mary Murphy told PEOPLE after the show. "We had a lot to celebrate tonight in the fact that [the contestants] held their own.”

But the celebrating came to an end when host Cat Deely announced the bottom two boys and bottom two girls: Witney Carson, 18, Audrey Case, 18, George Lawrence II, 19, and Cheyon Wespi-Tschopp, 23.

"It was a really tough call," Murphy said about having to choose which boy and girl to send home. And for the first time in season 9 the decision was not unanimous between the judges.

"At first it was really Audrey [staying], but by the time things were done it swung over to Whitney," said Murphy of the flip-flopping that took place before the decision to send Case home. "I think there have been more moments in the show that we have said, 'You are a star' to Whitney."

Factoring into the decision was Carson's well-reviewed jazz routine with season 1 winner Nick Lazzarini earlier in the evening.

"I couldn't have asked for a more perfect pairing," Lazzarini said of working with Carson. "From the first week of the show I thought, 'This girl is amazing.' "

Yet Murphy was quick to note that Case had been a deserving member of this season's Top 10.

"She has amazing legs and feet and she can use them," Murphy said. "She's just the cutest little girl, but I think that is the thing – there is just a little bit more of a maturity level in Whitney's performances."

Deciding which boy to send home proved slightly less contentious for the judges.

"They are both fabulous dancers," Murphy said of Wespi-Tschoop and Lawrence II. "Except Cheon's solo, my god."

Murphy, along with judge Nigel Lythgoe and guest judge – and Black Swan choreographer – Benjamin Millepied (a.k.a. Natalie Portman's husband) ultimately decided to save Wespi-Tschoop.

'He was like a dance warrior tonight," Murphy said of the ballet-trained dancer. "I looked over at Nigel afterwards and I was like a little kid, 'Wow, did you see that?' It was a lot of fun."

Your Reaction

Follow Us

On Newsstands Now

Lupita Nyong'o: Most Beautiful!
  • Lupita Nyong'o: Most Beautiful!
  • Chelsea Clinton is Pregnant!
  • Exclusive Royal Tour Diary

Pick up your copy on newsstands

Click here for instant access to the Digital Magazine

blog comments powered by Disqus

From Our Partners

Watch It

What to Watch Today

From Our Partners

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters