The Talk Hosts Go Makeup-Free
09/10/2012 AT 07:30 PM EDT
The five women – Sharon Osbourne, Julie Chen, Sara Gilbert, Aisha Tyler and Sheryl Underwood – went au naturel on the season premiere of their show, wearing no makeup or fake eyelashes, and sporting nothing but white robes.
Walking out with their hands covering their faces, the ladies eventually revealed their makeup-free selves to the audience, who was equally underdone.
"Gorgeous," the hosts gushed when Osbourne's face was revealed alongside a shot of her all done up.
"She has the best skin, like on the planet, I think," Gilbert said.
But a modest Osbourne replied, "No, no, it's all bought and paid for."
Following the audience's laughter, the America's Got Talent judge told everyone, "I dyed my eyebrows, I dyed my eyelashes."
Osbourne and her co-hosts weren't the only celebrities to be made under. Jamie Lee Curtis and The Young and the Restless stars Melody Scott Thomas and Michelle Stafford – along with Katherine Kelly Lang from The Bold and the Beautiful also went makeup-free.