Arriving around 10:45 p.m. Hale – wearing a short white dress – and Haynes spent their evening with a big group of friends, who looked happy to be together.
"They were both in a great mood and enjoying the company," an onlooker tells PEOPLE.
Hale sipped on a glass of white wine as she excitedly chatted with a blonde female friend. Meanwhile, Haynes and friends ordered and shared several desserts just before midnight.
So happy to see this one @coltonlhaynesinstagr.am/p/PnotChwugx/
— Lucy Hale (@lucyhale) September 16, 2012
Spot a celebrity? Tweet us your sighting
— People magazine (@peoplemag) August 7, 2012@peoplemag with#CITA and it could appear on PEOPLE.com!



















