Cary Elwes and Robin Wright
Everett; Richie Buxo/Splash News Online
10/03/2012 AT 01:50 PM EDT
As you wish!
It's been 25 years since The Princess Bride
's magical tale first stole audiences' hearts.
To celebrate the anniversary – and the film's Blu-ray release on Wednesday – the cast reunited for a screening at Alice Tully Hall in New York on Tuesday.
and Cary Elwes
, whose on-screen love made the film a cult classic, joined Mandy Patinkin
(Inigo Montoya), Chris Sarandon (Prince Humperdinck), Wallace Shawn (Vizzini), Carol Kane (Valerie), Bill Crystal
(Miracle Max) and director Rob Reiner.
While the cast looked elated to be together again, the presence of Peter Falk (Grandfather) and André the Giant (Fezzik) – who have both passed away since the film's 1987 release – were sadly missed.