Tim Tebow and Camilla Belle
Brian Dowling/PictureGroup; Dimitrios Kambouris/Getty
11/01/2012 AT 12:35 PM EDT
Has self-described picky dater Tim Tebow
found that special someone?
According to new reports, the New York Jets quarterback, 25, has made his latest pass – not to a wide receiver but at actress Camilla Belle.
reports that the pair were spotted getting cozy Tuesday while doing a little bowling at Latitude 30 in Jacksonville, Fla. PEOPLE has confirmed they were bowling, but according to an observer, they were joined by Tebow's brother, Robby, and some friends. Says the observer: "This was not a romantic date. She was with him, his brother, and some friends."
But another source tells PEOPLE: "They are seeing each other and were romantic in Jacksonville. They were holding hands and very attentive to each other at Latitude 30."
Belle, 26, is best known for her roles in When a Stranger Calls
and 10,000 BC
, and for having once dated Joe Jonas
. They split in 2009.
Tebow, whose Jets are enjoying a bye week, said recently that he's looking for a girlfriend who is "sweet and kind – and that has a servant's heart."
He added: "It's about finding a girl who likes me for me, and not because of what I do, or who I am, or the name."
Reporting by STEVE HELLING and LINDA MARX