Survivor's Carter Williams: My Nice-Guy Strategy Didn't Work

UPDATED 12/08/2012 at 12:00 PM EST Originally published 12/07/2012 at 01:10 PM EST

Survivor's Carter Williams: My Nice-Guy Strategy Didn't Work
Carter Williams
Monty Brinton/CBS
Carter Williams was a very popular Survivor player who made no enemies and kept his entire tribe laughing with his sardonic one-liners.

That's why his tribesmates couldn't let him anywhere near the finals and voted him out on day 33. Williams, a 24-year-old track coach from Shawnee, Kan., dishes on how there was more to his strategy than meets the eye.

So, how are you today?
Well, I just watched myself get voted off Survivor. That was a bummer.

I'll bet.
I watched it and even though I knew it was going to happen, I sort of thought maybe I'd pull it off. But I didn't, which kind of sucks.

Lots of regrets?
That's Survivor. One person walks away with a million dollars, and 17 people walk away with a whole lot of regret. I don't know if you know this, but I'm one of the 17.

You're actually funny guy. Why didn't they show that on Survivor?
I have a lot of one-liners. I wish they had shown that more. As tormenting as the game is, as difficult as it is physically and emotionally, we had good times out there. We laughed. I became great friends with everyone out there. There were a lot of big characters out there, so I guess I just blended in.

Was it your strategy to make friends?
I really did have more strategy than that. There were a couple of players who I wanted to be like. Danni Boatwright won the game by being likeable and sweet, and performing well when her back was up against the wall. Ozzy [Lusth] won challenge after challenge. And people are going to disagree with this, but I like [Survivor: Nicaragua winner] Fabio Birza. He won because he was a loveable, goofy guy who performed well in challenges but was never a threat. I wanted to be a mix of the three of them.

Well, that strategy got you to sixth place.
I was having a conversation with Jeff Kent, and we were going over our strategy. He didn't think I had any plan, but when I started talking, he looked at me wide-eyed and said, "You need to sit back and let people underestimate you."

So did everyone else underestimate you?
I think so. People over-strategize in Survivor, and that's a good way to be voted out. RC came off as always strategizing. Penner was a big strategic player. It can be overwhelming to people, and it puts a target on your back. So I thought, "I'm gonna get to know these people, and I'm going to treat them well, and play this game as well as I can." I wanted to be honorable. But maybe I overplayed that, because no one wanted me in the finals because I hadn't made any enemies.

Lisa Whelchel has strategized through the season. Did you know it while you were on the island?
I did. You could see in her eyes and her voice that she was struggling with how to keep her word and still play the game. If you're constantly flip-flopping, you're constantly letting people down, and that can build animosity. But she really is a great lady, and we had a lot of great talks out there. I loved every person on the show.

Is there anything else you really wish they had shown?
When I won a challenge, I tried to give up my immunity necklace for more food for the rest of the tribe. Part of it was strategy – I wanted them to like me and not vote against me. But part of it was that we were really hungry out there.

This was a season with big characters, but we didn't really get to know you. What did we miss?
I can sound like Keanu Reeves, but I'm not dumb. I try to be a nice guy. You can treat people with respect as you compete against him, which I tried to do. I was having so much fun. I loved doing the challenges. I loved meeting people and becoming real friends with them. We played the game and voted each other out, but I got to meet a lot of people I would never have met otherwise, which was really great.

Your Reaction

Follow Us

On Newsstands Now

Bindi Irwin: Remembering My Dad
  • Bindi Irwin: Remembering My Dad
  • Adam Levine's Wedding Details!
  • James Garner: 1928-2014

Pick up your copy on newsstands

Click here for instant access to the Digital Magazine

blog comments powered by Disqus

From Our Partners

Watch It

What to Watch Today

From Our Partners