Andy Samberg and Joanna Newsom
02/25/2013 at 01:50 PM EST
It's no joke: Andy Samberg is engaged!
The former Saturday Night Live
funnyman popped the question to singer-songwriter Joanna Newsom after five years together, Samberg's rep confirms to PEOPLE.
In addition to her role as a singer-songwriter, Newsom, 31, also plays the harp, piano and harpsichord.
The Celeste and Jesse Forever
actor, 34, and Newsom attended the Independent Spirit Awards together
on Saturday, which Samberg hosted.
Perhaps Samberg was inspired by his recently married friend Justin Timberlake
– the Lonely Island singer attended Timberlake's nuptials to Jessica Biel
in Italy in October