Jay-Z and Jake Gyllenhaal
Patrick McMullan/Sipa, Charley Gallay/Getty
04/12/2013 at 06:00 AM EDT
Who even knew they were friends?
Surprise besties Jake Gyllenhaal
and Jay-Z kicked back at the rapper's 40/40 Club in New York City Monday night, watching the NCAA championship basketball game in the Owner's Lounge.
The two, joined by Swizz Beatz and Timbaland, exchanged a big hug when they met up, then spent the evening snacking on the club's signature wings and sipping D'Usse cognac.
"No one was clearly rooting for one team over the other," a source tells PEOPLE, but "the group could be heard cheering excitingly throughout the entire game."
After Louisville beat Michigan, 82-76, the men called it a night, leaving the club one by one.– Carlos Greer