09/11/2013 at 03:30 PM EDT
Walt Disney would have been proud.
Holly's Madison's dreams became a reality on Tuesday night with an over-the-top wedding
that could only happen at the Happiest Place on Earth.
"It was really spectacular," a wedding guest tells PEOPLE. "They spared no expense."
Madison and beau Pasquale Rotella tied the knot at Disneyland's New Orleans Square (the couple's 6-month-old daughter, Rainbow Aurora
, was the guest of honor) after an evening cocktail party.
Then the wedding party and its guests headed to the rides.
After a turn on the Pirates of the Caribbean, a train carried guests to the reception where they were treated to a private showing of Fantasmic!, the evening show that features pyrotechnics, live actors on the water surrounding Tom Sawyer Island.
With the park closed, guests noshed from a buffet of food and candy, and had the decision of eating from not one, but two cakes – one for her, and one for him.
Rotella produces large-scale electronic music festivals, so not just any wedding deejay would do. The couple danced to the sounds of Grammy-nominated deejay Kaskade while fireworks exploded overhead.
It was, according to the source, "truly a fairly tale."
The wedding comes three months after the couple was engaged
during the Electric Daisy Carnival while, no surprise here, aboard a Ferris wheel with an 18-carat yellow diamond ring
. They had been dating since late 2011.