11/25/2013 AT 07:05 PM EST
All throughout Movember
, PEOPLE is celebrating the finest facial hair ever to grace the upper lip (and only
the upper lip) of our favorite celebrities.
may have been the height of the mustache trend, but the carefree, innocent days of the 1990s also saw a few notable caterpillars.
In West Philadelphia, born and raised
Will Smith, circa 1995
, Will Smith's stubbly 'stache in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air
set him apart from the manicured mustache of his cousin Carlton.
8. Bill Murray
Bill Murray in Rushmore, 1998
As Bill Murray aged into one of our finest character actors, a sleazy 'stache (seen here in Rushmore
) helped him sell the transformation.
7. Steve Buscemi
Steve Buscemi in Fargo, 1996
There's no better example of a creep-stache than the one sported by that guy who played in Fargo, we think his name is Steve.
6. Ned Flanders
Ned Flanders in The Simpsons
Hey-diddly-ho, 'stacherino! By the time The Simpsons
ruled the airwaves, mustaches had mostly disappeared from the facial-hair menu; Flanders's 'stache marked him as harmlessly passé as his oversized sweaters.
5. Jeff Foxworthy
Jeff Foxworthy, 1998
Michael Okoniewski / Getty
With his impeccable mustache, redneck-spotting comedian Jeff Foxworthy looked smarter than a fifth-grader
Ron Galella / Getty
Sensual. Spiritual. Earthy. If new-age musician Yanni hadn't grown a mustache, we would have had to Photoshop one on him.
3. Got Milk?
The most buzz-worthy mustaches of the 1990s weren't made out of hair. As part of a push to get Americans to drink more milk, the National Milk Processor Education Program
launched an ad campaign that attempted to turn the milk mustache from embarrassing faux pas
to trendy style symbol. Soon milk mustaches were even more popular than the real ones: even women and children were sporting the iconic white splash on their upper lips.
2. Randy Johnson
Randy Johnson, 1998
Ron Vesely / Getty
In a sport that can sand down its players into anonymity, Randy Johnson stood out. The pitching ace's lanky frame helped, as did his party-hardy mullet. But the look was capped off by an intimidating mustache – sometimes, as seen here, accompanied by soul patch – that made the Big Unit a force of terror on the mound.
1. Sam Elliott
Sometimes, there's a man, well, he's the man for his time and place.
Sam Elliott, 1990
Ron Galella / WireImage
And then there's a man like Sam Elliott, whose raw masculinity seems to place him outside the bounds of time and space. With this look, he could be a Civil War general, a Wild West gunslinger, a Haight-Ashbury hippie – either way, the 'stache abides.