The police who booked the 35-year-old man for a burglary arrest found a set of different-colored eyes staring them down, framed by cat-eye makeup.
Connolly was picked up Friday in New Milford, N.J., for breaking into a family's home and stealing jewelry, credit cards and other valuables, the Cliffview Pilot reported. While the accused may have the look of a feline, he evidently doesn't have the animal's stealth.
Authorities arrested Connolly the same night of the burglary, after the cat-eyed criminal allegedly used one of the stolen debit cards at a local 7-Eleven. Sometimes, those Fancy Feast cravings can't wait.