Sarah Michelle Gellar Tweets Photo with Michelle Trachtenberg, Seth Green
02/14/2014 AT 03:35 PM EST
Buffy the Vampire Slayer fans dying for an onscreen reunion got a taste of what could be Thursday, when the chosen one herself Tweeted a sweet photo with two former castmates.
Sarah Michelle Gellar, 36, posted a picture with Michelle Trachtenberg and Seth Green on the set of her new show The Crazy Ones.
"I get the best visitors," Gellar captioned the snapshot.
Green, 40, has been busy with FOX's Dads, but back in the day he played rocker werewolf Oz on the late '90s cult classic. Though Trachtenberg, 28, made waves as the diabolical Georgina on Gossip Girl, she got off to a more innocent start as Buffy's little sister, Dawn.
Now, we just need witchy Willow (Alyson Hannigan), sarcastic Xander (Nicholas Brendon) and soulful vampire Angel (David Boreanaz) to pay SMG a visit. The Hellmouth may have been closed forever, but our hearts are forever open to the Buffyverse.