Good Luck, Good Wife: 13 TV Shows That Survived Killing off Major Characters

03/24/2014 at 12:00 PM EDT

'The Good Wife' Death: 13 TV Shows That Killed Off Major Characters
Diane (Christine Baranski) and Will (Josh Charles) in The Good Wife
John Paul Filo/CBS
Killing off a main character in a television show is a risky move: You're upending the show's world (and putting a coworker out of a job) in the hope that the shake-up will lead to something greater down the line. And guess what? Despite the ministrations of fans, who claim that they will never watch their favorite show without [insert character name here], it often works!

Below, 13 shows that did the same thing The Good Wife did Sunday night, and not only survived, but thrived.

Warning: Major spoilers for all of these shows below!

Teen Wolf



Character: Allison Argent (Crystal Reed)

Cause of death: Stabbed by an Oni demon

Time on series: Three seasons

Fan reaction: Distraught enough that MTV launched a memorial site where fans could pay their last respects with the hashtag #GoodbyeAllison

House of Cards



Character: Zoe Barnes (Kate Mara)

Cause of death: Pushed in front of a subway train by Frank Underwood (Kevin Spacey)

Time on series: One season, plus one episode

Fan reaction: Surprised, though Netflix's release strategy meant nobody was sure when exactly they were allowed to talk about it

Homeland



Character: Nicholas Brody (Damian Lewis)

Cause of death: Executed by the government of Iran in a public hanging

Time on series: Three seasons

Fan reaction: "They should have done it in season one"

Downton Abbey



Character: Matthew Crawley (Dan Stevens)

Cause of death: Automobile accident brought on by behind-the-scenes drama

Time on series: Three seasons

Fan reaction: Heartbroken (British version); heartbroken and spoiled (American version)

The Walking Dead





Character: Lori Grimes (Sarah Wayne Callies)

Cause of death: Complications from pregnancy in a post-apocalyptic zombie dystopia

Time on series: Three and a half seasons

Fan reaction: Relieved, yet surprised by their own grief

Boardwalk Empire



Character: Jimmy Darmody (Michael Pitt)

Cause of death: Shot by former mentor Nucky Thompson (Steve Buscemi)

Time on series: Two seasons

Fan reaction: Shocked but intrigued for the future of the series

Game of Thrones



Character: Eddard Stark (Sean Bean)

Cause of death: Executed after losing the metaphorical game of thrones

Time on series: One season

Fan reaction: A slow realization that evil always triumphs and everyone good is doomed (unless they read the books, in which case they learned that lesson a long time ago)

Dexter



Character: Rita Morgan (Julie Benz)

Cause of death: Murdered in a bathtub by the Trinity Killer

Time on series: Four seasons

Fan reaction: Oddly captivated

Grey's Anatomy



Character: George O'Malley (T.R. Knight)

Cause of death: Struck by a bus after pushing a stranger out of its path

Time on series: Five seasons

Fan reaction: Muted

E.R.



Character: Mark Greene (Anthony Edwards)

Cause of death: Brain cancer

Time on series: Eight seasons

Fan reaction: Saddened, though E.R. had killed off enough minor characters by then to lessen the blow

24



Character: Teri Bauer (Leslie Hope)

Cause of death: Shot by CTU mole Nina Myers (Sarah Clarke)

Time on series: One season

Fan reaction: Devastated (though in the pre-social-media era fans had to deal with their grief privately)

South Park



Character: Kenny McCormick (voiced by Matt Stone)

Cause of death: Killed by aliens, an elevator and Ozzy Osbourne, among others; he died seemingly for good in the 2001 episode "Kenny Dies," but returned a year later

Time on series: Seventeen seasons and counting

Fan reaction: Unfazed

M*A*S*H



Character: Henry Blake (McLean Stevenson)

Cause of death: Shot down over the Sea of Japan during the Korean War

Time on series: Three seasons

Fan reaction: Unprecedented – the first major-character death on American television earned the CBS sitcom hundreds of letters of complaint from outraged viewers





Follow PEOPLE on Facebook!




Your Reaction

Follow Us

On Newsstands Now

Bindi Irwin: Remembering My Dad
  • Bindi Irwin: Remembering My Dad
  • Adam Levine's Wedding Details!
  • James Garner: 1928-2014

Pick up your copy on newsstands

Click here for instant access to the Digital Magazine

blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement

From Our Partners

Watch It

What to Watch Today

From Our Partners