First album: "Michael Jackson's Thriller, and I loved it. Everybody in the U.S. had to be moonwalking!"
Gary Miller / Getty
First album: "Bush's Razorblade Suitcase – random! I was on a choir trip and bought a couple of CDs my mom wouldn't have wanted me to buy if I was with her. I loved it. I'm pretty sure I still have it somewhere."
Jason Merritt / Getty
First album: "Shania Twain's Come on Over. It's still great!"
Frederick Taylor / Broadimage
First album: "I was 6 or 7 and it was a compilation album – I don't know why but it was called Bobby Dazzler. It was kind of like one of those Now Music albums – just the greatest hits of the time."
First album: "The Elvis album, the one with his name in light bulbs (Elvis (NBC TV Special)). It had "If I Can Dream," and that's one of my favorite songs."
Keith Mayhew / Landmark / JPI
First album: "The theme from The Dukes of Hazzard – the single. I was in second grade and every little boy in the world wanted to be the Dukes. I knew who Waylon Jennings was but that wasn't it. It was about the 'Good Ol' Boys.' I got to sing it with Waylon on the radio once."
For more on today's hottest country stars, pick up the new issue of PEOPLE Country on newsstands, or download the enhanced digital issue in the PEOPLE app in the Apple iTunes store. For full access to PEOPLE — including the digital Country issue, bonus Country extras only for subscribers, our weekly magazine and more— click here