Latest News!
- John McCain & Sarah Palin on Shattering the Glass Ceiling
- David Duchovny Has Addressed Rumors of Sex Addiction
- Five Things You Didn't Know About Sarah Palin
- Jennifer Aniston to Appear on 30 Rock
- Ben Affleck's Unconventional Convention Week
- John McCain Picks Sarah Palin as Running Mate
- Michael Phelps, Medalists to Join Oprah Winfrey
People Top 5
LAST UPDATE: Thursday August 28, 2008 11:10PM EDT
PEOPLE Top 5 are the most-viewed stories on the site over the past three days, updated every 60 minutes
Britney's Song All Her Own, Says Judge
A federal judge in Philadelphia has dismissed a lawsuit claiming that the pop princess absconded with the song of two local songwriters.
Originally posted Wednesday May 28, 2003 01:00 PM EDT
Britney Spears is in the clear after a federal judge dismissed a copyright infringement lawsuit by two Philadelphia songwriters who claimed the pop princess copied the melody of one of their songs, the Associated Press reports.
Spears's song in question, "What U See (Is What U Get)," was based on Michael Cottrill and Lawrence Wnukowski's "What You See Is What You Get," the pair claimed in their suit, filed last June.
But U.S. District Judge Berle M. Schiller said the men lacked sufficient evidence to prove that she even had access to their song.
"As plaintiffs have not come forward with any affirmative evidence showing access, there is no reasonable possibility that the creators copied plaintiffs' song before November 1999 when the melody of defendants' song was completed," Schiller wrote in his decision.
Cottrill and Wnukowski had claimed that, when asked in late 1999, they submitted a copyrighted version of their tune to one of Spears's representatives.
But Schiller, citing defense testimony, noted that the melody of Spears' song was completed by the beginning of November 1999, before Spears and her representatives "would have had access to a copyrighted version of plaintiffs' song."
He also said there weren't enough similarities between the two songs to prove copyright infringement.
In other Britney news, Spears, 21, announced last week that she is auctioning off more than 160 personal items, with proceeds benefiting her charity, the Britney Spears Foundation, which operates a weeklong performance arts camp for disadvantaged children.
Among the items going on the block will be her ears from her days on "The Mickey Mouse Club."
Spears's song in question, "What U See (Is What U Get)," was based on Michael Cottrill and Lawrence Wnukowski's "What You See Is What You Get," the pair claimed in their suit, filed last June.
But U.S. District Judge Berle M. Schiller said the men lacked sufficient evidence to prove that she even had access to their song.
"As plaintiffs have not come forward with any affirmative evidence showing access, there is no reasonable possibility that the creators copied plaintiffs' song before November 1999 when the melody of defendants' song was completed," Schiller wrote in his decision.
Cottrill and Wnukowski had claimed that, when asked in late 1999, they submitted a copyrighted version of their tune to one of Spears's representatives.
But Schiller, citing defense testimony, noted that the melody of Spears' song was completed by the beginning of November 1999, before Spears and her representatives "would have had access to a copyrighted version of plaintiffs' song."
He also said there weren't enough similarities between the two songs to prove copyright infringement.
In other Britney news, Spears, 21, announced last week that she is auctioning off more than 160 personal items, with proceeds benefiting her charity, the Britney Spears Foundation, which operates a weeklong performance arts camp for disadvantaged children.
Among the items going on the block will be her ears from her days on "The Mickey Mouse Club."
Check out more on... Britney Spears
Advertisement
Today's Photos
What's Hot on People.com
Promotion
Treat Yourself! 4 Preview Issues
















