Credit: Photos Illustration by Tiffany Hagler-Geard; Photos Provided by Startraks and INF Photo
Published: Tuesday May 19, 2015 13:30 PM EDT
More from PEOPLE
- Bachelor in Paradise's Jade and Tanner Say 'I Do!'
- Read the Cover Story: Ryan Reynolds: Sexiest Dad Alive
- Ryan Reynolds Played Marvin Gaye While Blake Lively Was in Labor: It Was Like 'Knives Coming Out of Her Eyes'
- It's a Boy! Charles and Cassie Kelley Welcome a Son – See His First Photo
- Tori Kelly Joins The Voice as Adam Levine's Advisor