• 2005 photo | Carrie Underwood

Credit: Nicolas Khayat/Abaca; Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic

Published: Thursday October 31, 2013 13:00 PM EDT

2013

2005

It's hard to believe these two photos are from the same evening. But Carrie Underwood proves that she's versatile when it comes to style, donning a ruffled gown one moment and dressing up as a Stevie Nicks impersonator the next.