Inside David Tutera's Whimsical Birthday Bash for Daughter Cielo

With bubbles, flowers and sweet treats, the wedding guru created an adorable Alice in Wonderland-themed party for his baby girl

BIG IS BETTER

"I always say 'something simple' which always turns out to be something not so simple. It was called Cielo in Wonderland, which is of course a play on Alice in Wonderland and it was a lot of detail," David Tutera told PEOPLE about planning his daughter's first birthday party, which included actors dressed up as the White Rabbit, Mad Hatter and the Cheshire Cat.