'85 vs. '05: Sexy Then & Now

From Sean Penn to Ben Affleck and Michael J. Fox to Adam Brody, see how sexy has changed since PEOPLE's first SMA. By Janice Morris

SEXIEST ATHLETE

1985: In the '85-'86 NFL season, Chicago Bears quarterback Jim McMahon won a Super Bowl title – and the nickname Mad Mac, thanks to his taste for mooning helicopters and partying with stars like Bruce Willis.

2005: After winning his second Super Bowl, New England Patriots QB (and former altar boy) Tom Brady donned a tux to escort fiancée Bridget Moynahan to New York City's chic Costume Institute Gala.