Mel Gibson: 1985
Long before courting controversy with The Passion of the Christ, PEOPLE's inaugural Sexiest Man Alive was simply "the most gorgeous man I've ever met," actress Sigourney Weaver said about azure-eyed Gibson, who was then starring in Mad Max: Beyond Thunderdome. Uneasy with his growing fame, the father of seven (with wife Robyn) lamented at the time, "It's all happening too fast."
Next Photo