Breaking

PEOPLE Magazine Awards News, Photos & More

Who Should Win Idol? Vote!

It's down to two: Katharine or Taylor? Pick your favorite

KATHARINE VS. TAYLOR

Taylor: Mr. Soul Patrol is a cross between a young Michael McDonald and someone's dad at a wedding after two glasses of Merlot (those dance moves!).
Katharine: She's, more simply, Kat – lithe on the floor with a sexy, sweet smile and a big voice that's hit or miss.