Who Would You Date? Vote Now

Luke vs. Owen, Ryan vs. Simon – which single guy is a good match? Vote!

Credit: Thomas Hinton/Splash News; Brian Prahl/Splash News

Updated: Thursday May 18, 2006 | 12:00 PM EDT

CLYDE PICKLER VS. MICHAEL LOHAN

Which jailbird dad piques your inner rebel: Kelly's (of American Idol) or teen queen Lindsay's?