Star Bodies: Hot or Not?

Too thin? Just right? Vote on Keira Knightley, Lindsay Lohan and others – then and now. By Julia Wang


THEN: "Everyone's a critic!" Boyle (left, in 2003) once told PEOPLE about her weight. "I eat pizza, I eat cookies. I'm fine."

NOW: The Las Vegas actress, who recently unveiled a fuller bikini body in Malibu, has since sworn off discussing the touchy subject. "We give it way too much publicity," she says.