Star Bodies: Hot or Not?

Too thin? Just right? Vote on Keira Knightley, Lindsay Lohan and others – then and now. By Julia Wang

LINDSAY LOHAN

THEN: Lohan (left, in 2005) denied ever saying she was bulimic, instead attributing her year of living dangerously thin to a hospital stay where she lost weight and "then wanted to keep it off."

NOW: "Sometimes being that thin doesn't look healthy," says the actress, who flaunted her curves in Malibu over Fourth of July weekend.