True Country vs. New Country Style: Vote!

Do you like Gretchen, Faith and others down-home or decked out? Weigh in – then see the results in PEOPLE's Country Music Special issue, on newsstands Oct. 13.

5 of 9

CARRIE UNDERWOOD

The American Idol star is a prairie girl in a white eyelet dress and cowboy boots at a Morristown, Ohio, concert (left), but is every bit the glamour girl in a curve-hugging tiered gown at the CMAs.