Smooth vs. Scruffy: What's Hotter?

Sexy stars – George! Justin! Leo! – have been experimenting with facial hair, but is it a hot look? You decide! By Julia Wang

7 of 14

CLAY AIKEN

The pop star wears his hair (facial and otherwise) a thousand different ways. He shocked Claymates during a performance on American Idol (left, in May), and by August had added a hint of scruff to his usual clean-cut look.