Idol's Most Memorable Auditions

The freaks, the stalkers and the ones who got away. Here are the best moments so far from this year's American Idol auditions

15 of 22

CITY OF CREEPY LOVE

Also in Philadelphia was Paul Martarano, whose super creepy love song to Paula Abdul shocked the judges and probably kept them up at night.

Next Photo

More Idol

Updated: Thursday Jan 31, 2008 | 12:00 PM EST

Add PEOPLE Photos
  •  | 
Advertisement