Jim Carrey & Jenny McCarthy: Their No-Regrets Love

The funny duo may have called it quits, but they'll always have their good times – revisit their LOL-filled romance!

THE BEGINNING

Carrey and McCarthy first took their love public in June 2006 – even holding hands at an L.A. Radiohead show. They "were having so much fun," a concertgoer told PEOPLE. "It was like you were watching a romantic comedy."