All My Children's Superstar Alumni

Before the lights go out on the ABC soap, see the A-listers – Amanda Seyfried! Josh Duhamel! Kelly Ripa! – who got their first big break on AMC


Long before she starred as a religious teen on HBO's Big Love, Seyfried played goody-goody tattletale Joni Stafford on the soap from 2002 until 2003. "I kill myself trying to do the right thing, and I'm the freak on the God squad!" Seyfried laments to bad boy J.R. (Andrew Ridings).