TVWatch
James Durbin's Best American Idol MomentsHe wanted to give metal a chance – and he did! Watch the rock star-to-be in action
More from PEOPLE
MAY 11
On his final performance before elimination, James worked with Lady Gaga to prepare "Love Potion No. 9." The results were impressive, though not enough to keep him in the competition. Randy said, "You're having a moment every week." Here's to more moments to come!
