Lauren Alaina and Scotty McCreery's American Idol Finale SongsThe finalists performed three songs each before the last night of voting began – vote for your favorite

9 of 10

WHO'S THE AMERICAN IDOL?

After three rounds of competition, Randy gave a "slight edge to Lauren Alaina," while Steven said, "Lauren gets it hands down." But it's not up to the judges – it's up to the voting public and, as Jennifer said, "It's a tight race. America has their job cut out for them."