The Stars of American Pie: 10 Years Later

More than a decade after the film's release, catch up with the cast for another serving of Pie


Hannigan was playing shy sidekick to Sarah Michelle Gellar on Buffy, the Vampire Slayer when she got cast as band geek Michelle Flaherty. Following the series' end in 2003, she wed Buffy costar Alexis Denisof, and two years later, returned to TV as Lily Aldrin on How I Met Your Mother. The couple welcomed their first daughter, Satyana, in 2009, and have another on the way.