Jennifer Aniston's Famous Men

From Justin to Brad to John to pup Norman, look back at the loves of the actress's life

GERARD BUTLER

The Bounty Hunter costars' flirtation seems to play out when the cameras aren't rolling: They are spotted hand-in-hand (and with the Scottish actor's hand on her backside) as the two promote their film in 2009. "I literally became a member of her family," Butler told PEOPLE of their relationship a year later.