The singer stays stylish while Christmas shopping in N.Y.C. Plus: Rihanna, Ellen & Portia, Hilary Duff and more
Published: Wednesday Dec 26, 2012 | 05:00 PM EST
More from PEOPLE
- Bernie Sanders Warns the Democratic Convention Could Get 'Messy' as Hillary Clinton Refuses Final Debate
- Read the Cover Story: Céline Dion: 'I Lost the Love of My Life'
- Drew Peterson Admitted to Killing His Missing Wife Stacy Peterson, Inmate Testifies
- Jake Pavelka Wasn't the Only Repeat on Last Night's Bachelorette: Guess Which Celeb Wore Jojo's Dress First
- Strong's Gabrielle Reece Had to Work for Her Healthy Body Image