5 Reasons We're Mourning Michelle Williams & Jason Segel's Split

From their low-key love to fun times with Matilda, this celebrity couple seemed made for each other

2. HE TOOK TO DADDY DUTY WITH EASE

Besides Williams, the star's 7-year-old daughter, Matilda, seemed equally smitten with the How I Met Your Mother actor, who frequently accompanied his ladies on excursions around New York City, such as a visit to the Bronx Zoo and a Jersey Boys performance on Broadway. Segel even tended to Matilda solo in July 2012 when Williams was away for work.