25 Seasons of Bachelor & Bachelorette Contestants Behaving BadlyFrom Jake and Vienna's sloppy public spat to Jason Mesnick's change of heart, relive the best of the worst moments in Bachelor history

STACEY ELZA

Watch the clip
It was the most embarrassingly awkward icebreaker in the show's history. On the very first night, Elza came bearing gifts for Matt Grant – a pair of her underwear that she tried to shove in his pocket. Grant was flabbergasted, and not in a good way. "There were 24 other girls, and I had to find a way so that I was going to stick out," Elza told PEOPLE. "It wasn't by sitting there, smiling in conversation. It was going to be by doing something outrageous." It didn't help that she was a little tipsy.