Almost Famous: Stars Who Love 'Real' Men

See how Christina Aguilera, Sofia Vergara, Scarlett Johansson and more found love outside of Hollywood.

REESE & JIM

Following a divorce from Ryan Phillippe and a breakup with Jake Gyllenhaal, Witherspoon found love with entertainment agent Jim Toth, whom she married in 2011. "Jim knows Reese is the one for him," a source told PEOPLE following their 2010 engagement. "It's what he's been waiting for. [Getting engaged] is a natural step for them." Never too far from the spotlight, the couple – who welcomed son Tennessee in 2012 – is known to rub elbows with celeb pals like Anne Hathaway.