Blindsided by the Bachelor and Bachelorette: 10 Times Contestants Were Shocked To Be Sent Home

These ten contestants did not expect to be dumped

THE BACHELOR SEASON 18: CLARE

As one of the most controversial bachelors in Bachelor history, it makes sense that we have another dramatic exit – this one, from Clare Crawley. In the finale, Juan Pablo whispered to Clare that he loved "f---ing" her, but didn't know her. Really, bro? Naturally, she flipped out – and got out.