How I Met Your Mother's 10 Most Delicious Moments

From the "pineapple incident" to the mystery of the slutty pumpkin, look back at the storylines that gave us food for thought


While flying solo at the season one wedding of a friend, Ted hits it off with guest Victoria (Ashley Williams), whom he nearly kisses until she insists she'd rather keep their one night of flirting chaste. The next day, realizing he wants to pursue a relationship, Ted badgers members of the wedding party to learn her full identity until the bride inadvertently tips him off: Revealing the wedding cake was made by Buttercup Bakery, Ted remembers Victoria gave "buttercup" as a nickname, and reunites with the pastry chef.