How I Met Your Mother's 10 Most Delicious Moments

From the "pineapple incident" to the mystery of the slutty pumpkin, look back at the storylines that gave us food for thought


Having secretly sipped wife Lily's fruity cocktails for years, Marshall finally musters the courage to order his own at MacLaren's Pub in season eight, requesting an elaborate mix of coconut rum, peach schnapps, vanilla vodka, strawberry creme liqueur, cranberry juice and sugar garnished with maraschino cherries and served in a tall, stemmed glass with a swirly straw. Hoping to christen the drink the Minnesota Tidal Wave, Marshall is surprised to learn that the concoction already has a name: the Robin Scherbatsky, an ode to Robin's frequent orders.